TY - JOUR
T1 - Study of the effects of PR toxin, mycophenolic acid and roquefortine C on in vitro gas production parameters and their stability in the rumen environment
AU - Bertuzzi, Terenzio
AU - Masoero, Francesco
AU - Giuberti, Gianluca
AU - Gallo, Antonio
AU - Moschini, Maurizio
PY - 2015
Y1 - 2015
N2 - Moulds belonging to Penicillium section roqueforti are common contaminants of feedstuffs and produce several
mycotoxins that can cause health hazards when ingested by farm animals. Among these, PR toxin (PR),
mycophenolic acid (MY) and roquefortine C (RC) have been frequently detected in forages, particularly silages.
The aims of the current trials were to study the effects of the presence of pure mycotoxins on in vitro rumen
fermentation parameters and to assess their stability in the rumen environment. Two successive in vitro gas
production experiments were carried out: a central composite design with four replications of central point (CCD)
and a completely randomized design with a fully factorial arrangement of treatments (FFD). In CCD, the effects of
PR, MY and RC concentrations in diluted rumen fluid (i.e. 0·01, 0·30, 1·01, 1·71 and 2·00 μg of each mycotoxin/
ml) were tested. Gas volume produced after 48 h of incubation (Vf) decreased linearly as concentrations of RC and
MY in diluted rumen fluid increased, with marginal effects similar for two mycotoxins, being respectively −14·6
and −13·4 ml/g organic matter (OM) for each 1·0 μg/ml of increment in mycotoxin concentration. Similarly, total
volatile fatty acid (VFA) production decreased quadratically as concentrations of RC and MY increased, with
marginal effects about two times higher for MY than RC, being −4·22 and −2·62 mmol/l for each 1·0 μg/ml of
increment in mycotoxin concentration. With respect to maximum Vf (i.e. 410·6 ml/g OM) and VFA (98·06 mmol/l)
values estimated by the model, decreases of 13·6 and 15·2% were obtained when incubating the highest RC
and MY concentrations, respectively. The PR did not interfere with rumen fermentation pattern and it was not
recovered after 48 h of incubation, whereas the stabilities ofMYand RC in rumen fluid were similar and on average
equal to about 50%. On the basis of CCD results, a second experiment (FFD) was carried out in which only effects
of MY and RC concentrations (i.e. 0, 0·67, 1·33 and 2·00 μg of each mycotoxin/ml of diluted rumen fluid) were
tested. Data from FFD showed Vf decreased linearly when concentrations of MY and RC increased, with marginal
effect two-folds higher for MY than for RC (−11·1 ml/g OM and −6·7 ml/g OM, respectively). Similar marginal
effects of MYand RC in decreasing VFA production were recorded: −2·38 and−2·86 mmol/l for each 1·0 μg/ml of
increment in mycotoxin concentration, respectively. At the highest RC and MY tested concentrations, Vf and VFA
decreased by 8·7 and 10·7%, respectively, over maximum estimated values. In FFD, the average amounts of MY
and RC recovered in rumen fluid after 48 h of incubation were 79·0 and 40·6%, respectively. In conclusion,
the MY and RC from standards interfered with rumen microorganisms at relatively low levels and were partially
stable in the rumen environment after 48 h of incubation. These findings suggested thatMY and RC could interfere
with digestive processes and might represent a potential risk for ruminants fed diets containing feeds contaminated
by mycotoxins produced by P. roqueforti.
AB - Moulds belonging to Penicillium section roqueforti are common contaminants of feedstuffs and produce several
mycotoxins that can cause health hazards when ingested by farm animals. Among these, PR toxin (PR),
mycophenolic acid (MY) and roquefortine C (RC) have been frequently detected in forages, particularly silages.
The aims of the current trials were to study the effects of the presence of pure mycotoxins on in vitro rumen
fermentation parameters and to assess their stability in the rumen environment. Two successive in vitro gas
production experiments were carried out: a central composite design with four replications of central point (CCD)
and a completely randomized design with a fully factorial arrangement of treatments (FFD). In CCD, the effects of
PR, MY and RC concentrations in diluted rumen fluid (i.e. 0·01, 0·30, 1·01, 1·71 and 2·00 μg of each mycotoxin/
ml) were tested. Gas volume produced after 48 h of incubation (Vf) decreased linearly as concentrations of RC and
MY in diluted rumen fluid increased, with marginal effects similar for two mycotoxins, being respectively −14·6
and −13·4 ml/g organic matter (OM) for each 1·0 μg/ml of increment in mycotoxin concentration. Similarly, total
volatile fatty acid (VFA) production decreased quadratically as concentrations of RC and MY increased, with
marginal effects about two times higher for MY than RC, being −4·22 and −2·62 mmol/l for each 1·0 μg/ml of
increment in mycotoxin concentration. With respect to maximum Vf (i.e. 410·6 ml/g OM) and VFA (98·06 mmol/l)
values estimated by the model, decreases of 13·6 and 15·2% were obtained when incubating the highest RC
and MY concentrations, respectively. The PR did not interfere with rumen fermentation pattern and it was not
recovered after 48 h of incubation, whereas the stabilities ofMYand RC in rumen fluid were similar and on average
equal to about 50%. On the basis of CCD results, a second experiment (FFD) was carried out in which only effects
of MY and RC concentrations (i.e. 0, 0·67, 1·33 and 2·00 μg of each mycotoxin/ml of diluted rumen fluid) were
tested. Data from FFD showed Vf decreased linearly when concentrations of MY and RC increased, with marginal
effect two-folds higher for MY than for RC (−11·1 ml/g OM and −6·7 ml/g OM, respectively). Similar marginal
effects of MYand RC in decreasing VFA production were recorded: −2·38 and−2·86 mmol/l for each 1·0 μg/ml of
increment in mycotoxin concentration, respectively. At the highest RC and MY tested concentrations, Vf and VFA
decreased by 8·7 and 10·7%, respectively, over maximum estimated values. In FFD, the average amounts of MY
and RC recovered in rumen fluid after 48 h of incubation were 79·0 and 40·6%, respectively. In conclusion,
the MY and RC from standards interfered with rumen microorganisms at relatively low levels and were partially
stable in the rumen environment after 48 h of incubation. These findings suggested thatMY and RC could interfere
with digestive processes and might represent a potential risk for ruminants fed diets containing feeds contaminated
by mycotoxins produced by P. roqueforti.
KW - PR toxin
KW - mycophenolic acid
KW - PR toxin
KW - mycophenolic acid
UR - http://hdl.handle.net/10807/65630
U2 - 10.1017/S0021859614000343
DO - 10.1017/S0021859614000343
M3 - Article
SN - 0021-8596
VL - 2015
SP - 163
EP - 176
JO - Journal of Agricultural Science
JF - Journal of Agricultural Science
ER -