Perceptions and outcomes of a fiscal bonus: Framing effects on evaluations and usage intentions

Edoardo Lozza, Albino Claudio Bosio

Risultato della ricerca: Contributo in rivistaArticolo in rivista

15 Citazioni (Scopus)


Is presenting a fiscal bonus as an income increase (a gain) the same as presenting it as a tax rebate (a loss reduction)? This paper aims to answer this question with two studies. Study 1 is a survey carried out in Italy to explore citizens’ perceptions of a fiscal reform introduced in 2005. It shows both effects imputable to the methods used to describe the bonus and differences between respondents belonging to different occupational groups. But it does not allow disentangling these factors. Study 2 aims to investigate whether and how (1) the frame used to describe a fiscal bonus and (2) taxpayers’ occupational status, influence their evaluation of this tax reduction and the uses they intend to make of it. To this end, 252 participants belonging to different occupational groups were submitted to two between-subject framing conditions (the bonus being described as a reduced loss or as a gain). They were then asked to evaluate the bonus’ importance for their personal wealth and to state how they intended to use it. Results demonstrate that the frame, rather than the occupational status of the respondent, influences taxpayers’ responses to the bonus. Respondents attached a higher importance to the bonus and were keener to save it when it was described as a loss reduction, compared to it being presented as a gain. These results are interpreted with reference to Prospect Theory, producing new insights into the processes through which framing can affect fiscal policy evaluations. The study is also relevant from a pragmatic perspective, as it shows that the way fiscal policy is communicated can be decisive for the achievement of economic and political goals.
Lingua originaleEnglish
pagine (da-a)400-404
Numero di pagine5
RivistaJournal of Economic Psychology
Stato di pubblicazionePubblicato - 2010


  • prospect theory


Entra nei temi di ricerca di 'Perceptions and outcomes of a fiscal bonus: Framing effects on evaluations and usage intentions'. Insieme formano una fingerprint unica.

Cita questo