TY - JOUR
T1 - Impact of digital therapeutics for the management of chronic diseases: systematic review
AU - Valentini, Ilaria
AU - Rumi, Filippo
AU - Cicchetti, Americo
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - Context
Nowadays, the increasing number of patients affected by metabolic, cardiovascular, and pulmonary
chronic diseases represents one of the major challenges for National Health Systems. Chronic illnesses
are the leading cause of hospitalisation, particularly among the elderly, posing sustainability issues due
to the massive quantity of resources required. The development of digital health provides a new model
for managing this type of health condition, which has improved the management of these patients and
reduced the related healthcare direct and indirect costs. The development of digital health has provided
a new management tool for chronic conditions. Digital therapeutics (DTx) are a subset of Digital Health.
They are evidence-based therapeutic interventions driven by high-quality software programs designed
to prevent, manage, or treat medical disorders or diseases. DTx can be used through web-based portals
or smartphone applications, which allows patients to self-care and lifestyle interventions to actively
engage in the management of their clinical condition.
Methods
This systematic review aims to synthesise recent literature on Digital Therapeutics to investigate their
impact in terms of clinical effectiveness and/or cost-effectiveness in the treatment of chronic diseases.
We systematically searched 4 databases (PubMed, Web of Science, Elsevier, and Scopus) to identify
articles on DTx published in the last five years (2017 to 2022), in accordance with the PRISMA
guidelines. We have selected only randomised controlled trials (RCTs) studies about DTx designed for
chronic disease management by identifying their effectiveness in terms of efficacy and cost outcomes.
We have included only studies in English. For the appraisal of the risk of bias, we have used the Risk of
Bias 2 Tool for RCT studies. The included studies were narratively summarised by categorising the DTx
according to the chronic diseases they were applied to.
Results
We retrieved 195 articles, out of which fourteen studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in
the review. In all the included studies, the intervention group used DTx for the treatment of chronic
diseases, while the control group received standard treatments without DTx. There are limited evidence
on the cost-effectiveness of DTx, with only two articles meeting the inclusion criteria. In all the included
studies, the DTx group showed significant evidence of improved patient parameters, reduced rehospitalisations, and decreased utilisation of healthcare providers, resulting in a reduction of costs in the
management of chronic disease patients. The methodological quality assessment revealed moderate to
high risks of bias, especially because blinding of patients was not possible due to the nature of the
intervention. This may have introduced some bias in the studies included in the review.
189
Discussion
This systematic review provides evidence for the impact of Digital Therapeutics in the management of
chronic diseases. The introduction of DTx has been shown to result in a significant reduction in costs
and an increase in the effectiveness and adherence of care, leading to an overall improvement in the
quality of life of patients compared to standard care. DTx is an emerging area, especially in the postpandemic scenario, due to its potential role in patient self-management by providing evidence-based and
personalised external support to chronic disease patients. Based on the results, an appropriate health
technology assessment framework would be a valuable tool to evaluate these products.
AB - Context
Nowadays, the increasing number of patients affected by metabolic, cardiovascular, and pulmonary
chronic diseases represents one of the major challenges for National Health Systems. Chronic illnesses
are the leading cause of hospitalisation, particularly among the elderly, posing sustainability issues due
to the massive quantity of resources required. The development of digital health provides a new model
for managing this type of health condition, which has improved the management of these patients and
reduced the related healthcare direct and indirect costs. The development of digital health has provided
a new management tool for chronic conditions. Digital therapeutics (DTx) are a subset of Digital Health.
They are evidence-based therapeutic interventions driven by high-quality software programs designed
to prevent, manage, or treat medical disorders or diseases. DTx can be used through web-based portals
or smartphone applications, which allows patients to self-care and lifestyle interventions to actively
engage in the management of their clinical condition.
Methods
This systematic review aims to synthesise recent literature on Digital Therapeutics to investigate their
impact in terms of clinical effectiveness and/or cost-effectiveness in the treatment of chronic diseases.
We systematically searched 4 databases (PubMed, Web of Science, Elsevier, and Scopus) to identify
articles on DTx published in the last five years (2017 to 2022), in accordance with the PRISMA
guidelines. We have selected only randomised controlled trials (RCTs) studies about DTx designed for
chronic disease management by identifying their effectiveness in terms of efficacy and cost outcomes.
We have included only studies in English. For the appraisal of the risk of bias, we have used the Risk of
Bias 2 Tool for RCT studies. The included studies were narratively summarised by categorising the DTx
according to the chronic diseases they were applied to.
Results
We retrieved 195 articles, out of which fourteen studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in
the review. In all the included studies, the intervention group used DTx for the treatment of chronic
diseases, while the control group received standard treatments without DTx. There are limited evidence
on the cost-effectiveness of DTx, with only two articles meeting the inclusion criteria. In all the included
studies, the DTx group showed significant evidence of improved patient parameters, reduced rehospitalisations, and decreased utilisation of healthcare providers, resulting in a reduction of costs in the
management of chronic disease patients. The methodological quality assessment revealed moderate to
high risks of bias, especially because blinding of patients was not possible due to the nature of the
intervention. This may have introduced some bias in the studies included in the review.
189
Discussion
This systematic review provides evidence for the impact of Digital Therapeutics in the management of
chronic diseases. The introduction of DTx has been shown to result in a significant reduction in costs
and an increase in the effectiveness and adherence of care, leading to an overall improvement in the
quality of life of patients compared to standard care. DTx is an emerging area, especially in the postpandemic scenario, due to its potential role in patient self-management by providing evidence-based and
personalised external support to chronic disease patients. Based on the results, an appropriate health
technology assessment framework would be a valuable tool to evaluate these products.
KW - systematic review
KW - digital therapeutics
KW - systematic review
KW - digital therapeutics
UR - http://hdl.handle.net/10807/298859
M3 - Meeting Abstract
SN - 2465-1753
VL - 2023
SP - 188
EP - 189
JO - PROSPETTIVE IN ORGANIZZAZIONE
JF - PROSPETTIVE IN ORGANIZZAZIONE
ER -